In California, voters rejected Proposition 40, a proposal to impose a one-time 5% tax on billionaires’ wealth. While the final numbers have yet to come in on November 9th, the Associated Press declared Proposition 40 a failure as Californians voted against the proposal.

Even in California, voters drew the line at giving government a direct claim on residents’ accumulated wealth: roughly 53% of voters opposed this legislation to tax a select group of individuals in order to fund more endless government spending.

The proposal’s defeat is good news for California, and the state’s experience teaches us an important lesson about tax policy: bad tax proposals can lead to unintended consequences.

Even before voters ruled against the misguided tax on specific individuals, some of those who would have been affected by the tax began to move away. This is a warning for Maine, where lawmakers have recently enacted a tax surcharge for high earners.

As it turns out, tax proposals can have an impact even before they’re passed.

What California Voters Rejected

Proposition 40, also referred to as the Billionaires Tax, would have required California-based billionaires to pay a one-time tax of 5% of their taxable net worth. This tax, unlike an income tax, would have been levied against accumulated wealth, including business and investment interests, regardless of whether that wealth had ever been liquidated.

Ninety percent of the revenue would have gone to healthcare, with the final 10% earmarked for education, food assistance, and paying for the administration of the tax. Proceeds would have begun in 2027.

Photo: Towfiqu Barbhuiya via Pexels

Supporters claimed this tax would produce an estimated $100 billion windfall. California’s Legislative Analyst’s Office believed this number was too high and instead projected the tax would bring in tens of billions of dollars over several years. They also warned that taxpayer responses could reduce ongoing income-tax collections.

A separate analysis projected an even clearer gap between the promised windfall and the long-term fiscal consequences. Assuming departures of billionaires holding approximately $1 trillion in combined wealth, it estimated that the proposed tax would collect about $55 billion spread over five years. However, in constant 2026 dollars, it ultimately would produce a net revenue loss cumulating to $49.7 billion between 2027 and 2046. This estimate accounted for the temporary wealth-tax collections and ongoing income-tax losses, but it did not include the broader effects on businesses, jobs, and investment.

California’s Gavin Newsom, as well as the California Teachers Association and Planned Parenthood of California, joined Republicans and business groups in opposing the measure out of concerns about its economic and fiscal effects. Gov. Newsom said that owning a valuable business does not mean having enough cash on hand to cover it.

This is of course true, and taxing that ownership could force businesses to sell assets, take out loans, or allocate resources that would otherwise be used to invest in growth. Spreading out payments over a number of years would affect the timing of the financial impact, but not eliminate it.

The Damage Began Before Election Day

One of the most important parts of this story happened before voters even went to the polls to decide whether or not to approve the wealth tax. Google co-founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin, along with several other billionaires, had already begun relocating out of California in anticipation of its passage.

Photo: Allen Boguslavsky via Pixels

In October, researchers published a paper noting that publicly confirmed departures had already diminished the wealth tax base by almost 30 percent. That paper also projected that California could lose more in long-term tax revenue than it would gain in the one-time windfall from a wealth tax.

The billionaires leaving California in anticipation of the wealth tax is not a projection, but a reality. Because of the January 2026 residency cutoff, billionaires were quitting California and moving their businesses elsewhere well before a vote even happened. The proposed residency deadline made the incentive especially clear. Someone facing a substantial tax bill could not safely wait until November to decide whether to move. By then, the date determining whether the tax applied would have passed.


Because of the January 2026 residency cutoff, billionaires were quitting California and moving their businesses elsewhere well before a vote even happened. 


California avoided imposing the tax, but it cannot assume the economic consequences disappeared with the election result.

After a credible proposal threatening to take a substantial share of people’s accumulated wealth, many moved away and reorganized their business affairs and lives elsewhere, before any such tax had even been enacted into law. There’s no obligation for them to return after defeating the measure, and most likely will not.

This demonstrates that even proposing a wealth tax can drive away the people, investment, and future tax revenue a state depends on, leaving lasting damage even if the tax never becomes law.

Maine Has Already Moved in the Wrong Direction

Earlier this year, Maine’s lawmakers voted for and passed an additional tax on those making over $1 million in taxable income for individual filers and $1.5 million for joint filers and heads of households. This raises the top marginal tax rate for those individuals above 7.15% to 9.15%.

Maine Policy Institute was opposed to the surtax, expressing that it’s disappointing that lawmakers continue to pass higher taxes without addressing the out-of-control spending that leads to calls for more taxes in the name of necessity. MPI also expressed concerns about how this tax on the wealthy will affect investment in the local economy, Maine’s business community and overall competitiveness, and the state’s ability to attract and retain successful people.

California’s proposed wealth tax differs from the surcharge in Maine in that the former is levied on accumulated assets, while the latter is levied only on annual taxable income above a certain threshold. Nonetheless, they both would affect business owners, professionals, and investors, and could influence their economic and residential choices.

If Maine legislators are considering a wealth tax or even a raise in income taxes on the highest earners, they should first consider what has happened in California. Successful people can choose where to live, where to conduct business, and where to invest, and part of the equation will be whether the state continues raising taxes.


If Maine legislators are considering a wealth tax or even a raise in income taxes on the highest earners, they should first consider what has happened in California. 


Maine needs to be careful not to send the message that wealth creation in this state will make those creators a target for the next tax proposal. A wealth tax, even just a proposed wealth tax, could undermine confidence and cause people to leave Maine before the government collects a single dollar of the tax.

Maine Should Not Take the Next Step

Implementing a new tax surcharge on high-earning individuals demonstrates that lawmakers in Maine are prepared to raise taxes on a select group to fund spending initiatives. But what has happened in California demonstrates some of the potential problems Maine lawmakers should consider before attempting to implement higher taxation policies.

Unlike California, Maine does not have a large number of billionaire residents and wealth holders. Consequently, implementing a tax on wealth intended to reach a broader pool of taxpayers in Maine would require a lower threshold. This approach would potentially tax individuals who own smaller businesses and portfolios.

Lowering the threshold would not solve the problems California encountered. Quite the opposite, it would expose more people to them. Business owners could face taxes on assets that produce little immediate cash, while the possibility of future increases could discourage people from bringing their businesses and wealth to Maine in the first place.

Maine should be pursuing the opposite goal. We need a competitive, predictable tax environment that encourages people to build businesses, invest, and remain here. That requires spending restraint and an understanding that private wealth is not an unlimited reserve account for state government.


We need a competitive, predictable tax environment that encourages people to build businesses, invest, and remain here. 


California voters made the right decision. Maine lawmakers should learn from both the rejection of the tax and the wealth flight that preceded it. The best way to avoid those consequences is to reject the premise before it becomes a serious proposal.