The Lewiston shooting on October 25, 2023, was a devastating incident that left 18 people dead and many more injured. In the aftermath, multiple investigations have been conducted to understand what went wrong and how such tragedies can be prevented in the future. The findings from the Independent Commission to Investigate the Facts of the Tragedy in Lewiston, as well as reports from the Army Reserve and other entities, have highlighted significant failures at various levels of government. These failures span local, state, and federal agencies. 

The Independent Commission’s interim report pointed to several critical lapses at the local level, particularly within the Sagadahoc County Sheriff’s Office. In September 2023, law enforcement had sufficient probable cause to take Robert Card Jr. into protective custody under Maine’s Yellow Flag law, which allows for the temporary removal of firearms from individuals deemed a threat to themselves or others. 

However, Sgt. Aaron Skolfield and his supervisors failed to take the necessary actions. Sgt. Skolfield did not make sufficient attempts to meet Card in person, did not consult agency records or contact relevant witnesses, and did not seek assistance from prosecutors or other law enforcement agencies. When Sgt. Skolfield went on leave, his supervisors failed to assign another deputy to follow up, effectively abandoning their responsibility.

The decision to delegate the removal of Card’s firearms to his family members, who lacked the legal authority to enforce such actions, was a significant error. This abdication of responsibility meant that the firearms remained in Card’s possession and contributed to the tragedy.

At the state level, the shortcomings in applying Maine’s Yellow Flag law reveal grave weaknesses, particularly in terms of training and enforcement. The lack of clear guidelines and adequate support for local law enforcement in handling mental health crises and assessing threats contributed to the failure to act decisively in this case. Moreover, the lack of better communication and coordination among various state agencies involved in mental health and public safety reveals another shortcoming of the state.

The federal response, particularly within the U.S. Army Reserve, has also come under scrutiny. An Army report revealed a series of failures by unit leadership, communication breakdowns between military and civilian hospitals, and inadequate handling of Card’s deteriorating mental health. The report criticized the Army Reserve Psychological Health Program for not thoroughly reviewing Card’s medical records before closing his case.

Furthermore, despite clear signs of Card’s mental health crisis, there was insufficient action taken to restrict his access to firearms. When the chief of the Army Reserve, Lt. Gen. Jody Daniels, was asked if sufficient steps were taken to inform local law enforcement agencies about Card’s medical records, he said, “The Army had contact with family members, and there was a miscommunication as to who was removing weapons, who had possession of weapons, but there were multiple instances of conveyances by Army Reserve personnel to recommend that those weapons be stored outside of SFC Card’s care.”

Failure Across Multiple Agencies

The Lewiston shooting tragically exposed significant failures across multiple levels of the systems designed to safeguard public safety. The failures occurred at the local law enforcement level, within state legal frameworks, and in federal military oversight. These failures highlight a critical need for better communication and coordination among all agencies involved.

Local law enforcement, specifically the Sagadahoc County Sheriff’s Office, failed to act decisively despite clear indications that Robert Card Jr. posed a serious threat to himself and others. The state’s legal framework, including Maine’s Yellow Flag law, was not effectively utilized to remove firearms from Card’s possession even though the law provided mechanisms to do so in cases similar to Card’s. At the federal level, the U.S. Army Reserve’s oversight was insufficient, with leadership and procedural lapses contributing to a lack of intervention during Card’s mental health crisis.

Had there been more effective communication and cooperation among these various agencies, the warning signs could have been addressed and the tragic events of October 25, 2023 might have been prevented. 

This case underscores the urgent need for comprehensive reforms and improved systems for better training and resources for law enforcement, clearer guidelines and support for applying protective measures like Maine’s Yellow Flag law, and improved coordination and communication across different levels of government and between military and civilian authorities.

Afua Kwarteng is a graduate student at the University of Maine pursuing a dual MBA and Global Policy degree. She graduated from the University of Ghana with a BA in Political Science and Swahili. She is passionate about state and international policy and is serving as Maine Policy Institute’s 2024 communications intern.