In 2016, Maine became the first state to adopt ranked-choice voting for statewide elections. Supporters presented it as a way to expand voter choice, produce majority winners, increase participation, reduce negative campaigning, encourage moderation, and provide the benefits of a runoff without requiring a second election.

In 2019 MPI released a report, A False Majority: The Failed Experiment of Ranked-Choice Voting, which examined 96 ranked-choice voting elections from across the country while evaluating some of the principal claims made in support of the system. That report provides the foundation for this updated analysis. Since then, Maine has gained substantially more experience with RCV through additional statewide contests, while new research, legal rulings, administrative problems, and changes to Maine’s tabulation rules have expanded the record available for review.

Nearly a decade after Maine adopted RCV, the state now has enough experience to test its promised benefits against the system’s actual operation. Maine has confronted exhausted ballots, delayed tabulations, administrative errors, recount limitations, constitutional disputes, changes to the technical rules governing candidate elimination, and more.

This report examines that record. It explains how RCV works, traces its legal and political history in Maine, and evaluates the key problems with RCV using election data, academic research, and Maine’s own experience.

Read the report here.