Maine’s Obamacare “Success Story” Falters

December 10, 2015 Posted by Nathan Strout - No Comments

Community Health Options, a Lewiston based health insurance co-op has announced that it will suspend new individual enrollment on December 15, a month and a half before the open enrollment period officially ends.

The co-op came to this decision after posting an $18 million shortfall in the third quarter—the first time they have reported significant losses.

Community Health Options is one of 23 co-ops established under the Affordable Care Act to offer low cost health care plans. The non-profits received federal funding and were meant to compete with for-profit insurers and drive prices down. In Maine, Community Health Options has proven to be immensely popular, seizing over 80% of the individual market.

The past few months, however, has seen over half of the co-ops fail. Although the co-ops demonstrated high enrollment numbers, the low premiums offered were unable to offset the higher than expected payouts. A Department of Health and Human Services report found that 22 of the 23 co-ops actually lost money in 2014. The only co-op to actually turn a profit was Maine’s Community Health Options, which has been touted as a success story by many—until now.

A press release from the Maine Bureau of Insurance notes that the decision for the company to suspend enrollment comes after significant losses in the third quarter. In a separate press release, Community Health Options explained that the losses were the result of “higher than expected claims costs in 2015.” While Community Health Options is quick to note that it will continue to fulfill its current obligations, it is unclear whether the non-profit will face further losses in the coming months.

“The claims coming in are higher than what we anticipated, higher on a per-member, per-month basis than last year,” CEO Kevin Lewis told the Lewiston Sun-Journal. “It’s hard to tell whether this is a new normal or whether this is a kind of a peak that will be followed by a lessening of claims and utilization.”

Federal funding for co-ops like Community Health Options has become increasingly limited since Obamacare went into effect. In a 2013 budget deal, Congress cut much of the federal funding available to the co-ops. While the Affordable Care Act contains a “risk corridor” program to offset major losses to health insurance companies like the co-ops, it has been unable to offset the industry’s major losses in the Obamacare exchanges.

According to the Maine Bureau of Insurance, the premiums approved for Community Health Options’ plans will not change.